Bought And Paid For

Written by Jim the Realtor

December 6, 2013

realtorstuffingflyerboxThe California Association of Realtors’ political action committee  gave $500,000 to the state Democratic Party the day before the Democrat-dominated Franchise Tax Board effectively resolved a months-long legislative fight over the state’s tax treatment of short sales.

Tuesday’s donation, reported Wednesday evening, matches the $500,000 the Realtors gave state Democrats in May. The group also gave the party $168,000 earlier in the year and more than $1 million in 2012.

The 2013 contributions, by far the largest to the party in the current election cycle, will help Democratic attempts to keep their two-thirds legislative supermajorities in 2014.

Realtors spokeswoman Lotus Lou denied any connection between the two events. Wednesday’s legal opinion from the Franchise Tax Board stemmed from a September clarification on the issue by the IRS, she said.

“The two did not have any relation to each other,” Lou said.

In her legal opinion, Franchise Tax Board chief counsel Jozel Brunett cited the clarification by the IRS that forgiven debt after a home is sold for less than the amount owed on it should not be treated as taxable income.

“This is welcome news for Californians who have had to short sell their homes this year,” Board of Equalization member George Runner said in a statement. “We learned last month they wouldn’t face a federal tax penalty. We now know they won’t face a state tax hit either.”

In the same statement, California of Realtors President Kevin Brown praised the “recent clarifications” as protecting “distressed homeowners from debt relief income tax associated with a short sale in California.”

The Franchise Tax Board is separate from the Board of Equalization, another tax board. Its three members are Controller John Chiang, Board of Equalization chairman Jerome Horton, and state Finance Director Michael Cohen, who answers to Gov. Jerry Brown. All are Democrats.

Such an administrative fix was never mentioned as a possibility during a legislative fight over the issue that spilled into a heated Senate campaign.

The Realtors lobbied heavily this year for legislation that would extend the 2012 state tax benefit for short sales. Supporters said it would put the state on the same page as the IRS, which has said that it does not view mortgage debt forgiveness as federal taxable income.

But Senate Bill 30 stalled after Senate Democrats linked the bill to another measure strongly opposed by the Realtors: Senate Bill 391, which would impose a $75 fee on real-estate transactions to raise money for affordable housing projects. Both bills are pending in the Assembly.

The animosity grew as the Realtors injected hundreds of thousands of dollars into last summer’s special election in the Central Valley’s 16th Senate District. The money either attacked Democrat Leticia Perez or supported Republican Andy Vidak, who won

“We are not convinced that ‘one-party control’ of the Legislature can or will produce effective policy development for California,” association president Don Faught wrote in a July email to The Bee.

Senate President Pro Tem Darrell Steinberg accused the Realtors of “scorched-earth” tactics.

This week’s mega-donation might ease some of those hard feelings. It comes as the Realtors have contributed the election-cycle maximum of $8,200 to several California lawmakers on both sides of the aisle.

10 Comments

  1. avgjoe

    thats a lot of coin. I guess buying votes is pretty pricey is this day and age?

  2. Susie

    CA Realtors spokeswoman Lois Lu denied any connection? Of course she did, she wanted to keep her job. But how she was able to say it without bursting out laughing is what really shocks me…

  3. Rob Dawg

    All my life I’ve made financial decisions/investments with tax consequences in mind. Where’s my free roll?

  4. Jim the Realtor

    Look how despicable and brazen this extortion was – right out in the open where everyone can see, the realtors give the politicians a half-mill to get their bill passed.

    Obviously this happens every day. http://www.realtor.org/rpac/rpac-contributions-in-election-cycles

    What is worse is we are so used to it – and numb – that major media outlets didn’t even consider this news. I plucked it off the SacBee!

  5. Jim the Realtor

    The only free roll for the non-poor was the waiving of the death tax for one year (2010), but you had to die correctly to take advantage!!

  6. Thaylor Harmor

    Money makes the world go around…and greases the skids too, apparently.

  7. Mozart

    So I suppose all this naive outrage would be absent if people were taxed on the short sale “income”? Of course, then it would be Democrats taxing us to death and we should all move to Idaho, right? Which I hope many do.

    The article also says they give to both sides of the aisle.

  8. elbarcosr

    Mozart, I don’t think the comments amount to a Dems vs Repubs slant; I think everyone knows if the Repubs were in control, they would have gladly taken the money with the same result.

  9. Jim the Realtor

    Yes, politicians welcome generous donations in exchange for votes, regardless of party affiliation.

    What bugs me is how it’s done out in the open, and the media ignores it. I’m still looking for another media outlet to cover this story, and nothing yet.

    The media is complicit.

    In addition, you’re not going to have a revolution without communication.

Klinge Realty Group - Compass

Jim Klinge
Klinge Realty Group

Are you looking for an experienced agent to help you buy or sell a home?

Contact Jim the Realtor!

CA DRE #01527365CA DRE #00873197

Pin It on Pinterest