Congresspeople Underwater

Written by Jim the Realtor

August 6, 2012

From the latimes.com:

SACRAMENTO — State lawmakers typically keep modest quarters near the Capitol to use when they’re in town, with help from their tax-free expense allowance of $28,000 a year.

Assemblyman Tony Mendoza bought a three-bedroom home instead, paying $463,000 for it after his 2006 election.

“If you bought property, property values would go higher,” said the Democrat, whose main home is in Artesia. “So I figured as soon as I get there [Sacramento], I will buy the house.”

But now he is one of at least 10 legislators who didn’t fare well in a real estate climate that once showed no sign of cooling. The housing market tanked, the recession lingered and legislators’ pay was cut.

Unlike some predecessors who made handsome profits on second residences in Sacramento or in their districts before the downturn, these lawmakers have found themselves unable to pay their mortgages or stuck with homes that would sell at a loss, or both.

At least five have endured foreclosures or short sales. The others have hung on; to do so, at least three have depended on people who work for them — and in Mendoza’s case, on a campaign donor as well.

As Mendoza nears the end of his final Assembly term, he says he owes $150,000 more on his Sacramento home than it’s worth. A longtime campaign contributor, Cecy Groom, who is also his accountant, rounded up investments of $42,000 to help him keep the home on Soaring Hawk Lane.

In filings required by the state, Mendoza reported receiving $6,000 each from Groom’s daughter and Beatriz Ricartti, a Los Angeles businesswoman who subsequently donated to Mendoza’s political coffers.

Covina physician Shura Moreno invested $30,000.

Moreno is under investigation by the Los Angeles County district attorney’s office, and five employees of his East Los Angeles medical clinic await trial on charges of defrauding the state’s Medi-Cal system, prescription fraud and other offenses.

“I was totally shocked by that,” Mendoza said.

Moreno would say only that he is not interested in taking over ownership of Mendoza’s house.

The lawmaker also rented a room in the house to fellow legislators and to Gabriella Villanueva, whom he hired in November 2010 as a legislative assistant for $60,000 a year. Villanueva paid him $500 a month in rent.

Villanueva said there was no tie between Mendoza’s giving her a job and her decision to rent from him, and she has since moved out, although she would not say when. She was hired just before a legislative pay cut was to take effect.

Mendoza has attributed his financial troubles partly to a salary cut, which cost him about $20,000. “I was paying the mortgage with that,” said Mendoza, whose annual compensation now is $123,000, including the tax-free per diem.

He said he wants to avoid losing his house and the money he has put into it: “If I break even, I will be happy.”

At least two other legislators are getting help with personal finances by renting to their aides, their financial disclosures show.

Assemblywoman Mary Hayashi (D-Hayward) and her husband bought a home in Castro Valley, in the Bay Area, for $698,0000 in 2004. When they put it on the market for $499,000 last year, it didn’t sell.

The pair’s residence today is in Hayward, also in the Bay Area. Hayashi legislative aide Christopher Parmon and his husband, Chabot College Chancellor Joel Kinnamon, occupy the Castro Valley house.

Parmon said he asked to live there. The couple began renting in February 2010, less than a month after Hayashi gave Parmon a $7,500 raise, lifting his salary 10% to $82,440.

Parmon said the raise was unrelated to his move to his boss’ property and declined to say how much it costs to live in the home. Hayashi’s financial disclosures show Kinnamon paid her between $10,000 and $100,000 in rent last year.

7 Comments

  1. livinincali

    Politician, probably one of the few jobs that’s almost always going to make more sense to rent than to buy unless you got the cushy lobbyist job lined up and plan to stay in the capitol after your term is over. You’re temporarily going to live in the capitol for as little as 2 years and then presumably go back to the district you came from.

    Of course considering that level of financial awareness it’s no wonder we’re constantly facing budget shortfalls and solutions to prop up home prices. They can’t even make a simple calculation on whether to it’s better to buy vs rent when you might only stay for a couple of years.

  2. shadash

    “At least two other legislators are getting help with personal finances by renting to their aides, their financial disclosures show.”

    Perfect way to funnel money from campaign funds to yourself. Just overpay staffers with the understanding that they live in your house at inflated rents.

    So many other things going on in this article I don’t want to even think about it.

  3. Jim the Realtor

    Agreed – having a slimy doctor give Mendoza $30,000 to keep him afloat, and then he says he is “totally shocked” to hear he is under investigation?

    Why do you think he gave you the money???

  4. Former RB Resident

    Technically, these aren’t “Congresspeople”, as you are talking about the state government. The DC area housing market, especially close in where most of them live when they are here, is doing quite well.

  5. Susie

    I’m with shadash and JtR! Alarm bells were going off incessantly in my head the more I read.

    And to think I graduated in political science. *Sigh* I guess–way back then–I naively thought I could help change the world. Alas, I’ve learned through the years, politicians generally are owned by lobbyists and the only world they change is their own financial ones…

  6. interesting

    @4, Laura Richardson is now a Congresswoman in DC and that Sacramento disaster wasn’t her only foreclosure. She’s a big ol’ can of worms all by herself (she was just “reprimanded by the House). http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/2chambers/post/house-approves-ethics-report-against-laura-richardson/2012/08/02/gJQAAXF2RX_blog.html

    Mary Hayashi was convicted of shoplifting at Neiman Marcus earlier this year. She claimed a brain tumor at the time but is now denying it because she’s running for Alameda County supervisor (replacing another disgraced Dem.)
    http://www.mercurynews.com/bay-area-news/ci_21128952

    And then there’s all those hiring and salary increases that allow staffers to help their bosses with their mortgages on top of the $28k legislators get tax free for their personal expenses.

    Ack, this stuff is so frustrating, distressing, and depressing. 🙁

  7. interesting

    Dang it! I did it again, I put two links in one post which sent me to moderation. 🙁

    Sorry, Jim. It’s been awhile since I commented and I forgot about the one link per post limit.

Klinge Realty Group - Compass

Jim Klinge
Klinge Realty Group

Are you looking for an experienced agent to help you buy or sell a home?

Contact Jim the Realtor!

CA DRE #01527365CA DRE #00873197

Pin It on Pinterest